Agenda item

The Future Delivery of Tenant Engagement

Report from the Executive Director of Adult Care, Housing and Public Health.

 

Recommendations

 

That Cabinet:

 

1.    Approve the proposal to introduce a hybrid model, with tenant engagement insourced and tenant scrutiny outsourced from April 2027.

2.    Approve the proposal to procure an external provider to manage and deliver a tenant scrutiny function.

 

Minutes:

Consideration was given to the report which presented the proposals to introduce a hybrid model for tenant engagement. The Council had outsourced a large proportion of its tenant engagement activity for Housing Services for many years. The initial term of the current contract was due to expire in March 2027.  The report proposed an approach to build on the strong foundation of tenant engagement in the Borough through a more agile model which better met the diverse needs of tenants, the requirements of the new housing regulations, and the need to respond swiftly to the changing regulatory environment, as required.


Rotherham Council had a strong history of effective engagement with its tenants and residents and had worked with a local provider, RotherFed, to successfully deliver engagement activity across the Borough for approximately 17 years. The current contract’s initial term was due to expire in March 2027. However, since the contract was last procured in 2023, there had been significant changes across the sector which focused on housing providers demonstrating how tenant feedback was heard, acted upon, and influenced decision making within Policy, service design and delivery and that the landlord must have a direct relationship with its tenant panels and groups. New expectations around this were set out in the Regulator of Social Housing’s Consumer Standards.


Whilst the current contract had performed well, there were some limitations which had prevented the Council and RotherFed from having the flexibility needed to respond to the sector’s changing requirements. These included data protection issues which reduced the current contract provider’s ability to carry out targeted engagement, and difficulties for the Council in evidencing clear outcomes due to an indirect relationship with tenants. It had also been challenging to provide clear evidence of how tenant views and feedback were used to shape and improve services.


Four options had been considered as part of the options appraisal, as detailed in Section 3 of the report:

 

a)    Re-procure and outsource the tenant engagement (including tenant scrutiny) service externally via a full tender process from April 2027.

b)    Introduce a hybrid model, with tenant engagement insourced and tenant scrutiny outsourced from April 2027.

c)    Fully insource the tenant engagement (including tenant scrutiny) service from April 2027.

d)    Extend the current contract for 12 months.

 

Option B (Hybrid Model) was the preferred option. This approach would bring most tenant engagement activity directly into Housing Services, strengthening accountability, oversight, visibility and alignment with the Tenant Engagement Framework, while retaining an externally delivered tenant scrutiny function to provide independence, specialist expertise and confidence in the rigour of scrutiny activity. This model provided the strongest overall response to the issues identified through the appraisal and offered the best balance between tenant confidence, regulatory assurance, service integration and deliverability.


Resolved:


That Cabinet:

 

1.    Approve the proposal to introduce a hybrid model, with tenant engagement insourced and tenant scrutiny outsourced from April 2027.

 

2.    Approve the proposal to procure an external provider to manage and deliver a tenant scrutiny function.

Supporting documents: