Agenda item

Overview and Scrutiny Management Board Scrutiny Review - Street Lighting Columns

Report from the Director of Policy, Strategy and Engagement.

 

Recommendations:

 

1.    That Cabinet receives the recommendations listed below, as approved by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board:

 

a.    Approve amendments to the Highway Asset Management Plan to incorporate a comprehensive framework for attachments to lighting columns and associated highway assets, setting out requirements relating to permitted and prohibited attachments, risk-based approval arrangements, structural testing and retesting requirements, applicant responsibilities, and enforcement provisions. The framework should apply consistently to all users of lighting columns, including the Council, Parish and Town Councils, contractors and third parties.

 

b.    Approve the development and publication of a standalone, publicly accessible Lighting Column Attachments Guidance Document, in consultation with Parish and Town Councils, to provide clear and practical guidance on the application of the Highway Asset Management Plan framework, including attachment classifications, approval processes, testing requirements, responsibilities, communication arrangements, and practical examples of acceptable and unacceptable attachments.

 

c.     Establish formal consultation, communication and engagement arrangements with Parish and Town Councils, including consultation on future policy changes, testing programmes and charging arrangements, together with sufficient advance notice of any financial implications to enable effective budget planning, procurement and decision-making.

 

d.    Establish clear categories for lighting column attachments, identifying which attachments are permitted without testing, permitted subject to approval and structural testing, or prohibited, and publish consistent standards for structural testing, assessment criteria, retesting intervals, validity periods and maximum permissible loading thresholds where appropriate.

 

e.    Continues to coordinate structural testing arrangements on a borough-wide basis where appropriate and considers longer-term funding, procurement and cost-sharing arrangements to minimise administrative burdens and secure value for money for Parish and Town Councils whilst maintaining compliance with relevant safety standards.

 

f.      Ensures arrangements are developed to support the continuation of community display schemes where lighting columns are unable to safely accommodate attachments, including consideration of alternative display solutions, targeted asset replacement where appropriate, the use of structural testing outcomes to identify trends, inform the Council’s future investment priorities, replacement programmes and wider asset management decisions.

 

g.    That the service engages in meaningful discussions with interested parties including Parish Councils, seeking to install displays on lighting columns, with the aim of reaching a shared understanding regarding the timescales and process for replacing damaged or missing columns, and to explore opportunities to facilitate timely installation where feasible.

 

h.    Strengthen the enforcement framework for unauthorised attachments by establishing clear compliance procedures and, where legally permissible, implementing arrangements for the recovery of costs incurred in the removal of unauthorised installations, and reviews the effectiveness of the new arrangements within 12 months of implementation, including consideration of feedback from Parish and Town Councils, testing outcomes and enforcement activity, with the findings reported to the relevant Scrutiny Board.

 

2.    That Cabinet formally considers its response to the above recommendations within two months of its receipt, in accordance with the Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rules.

 

3.    That in responding to these recommendations, it is requested that Cabinet’s response should identify the proposed actions, responsible officer(s), success measures and target completion dates for each recommendation.

 

Minutes:

Consideration was given to the report which presented the findings and recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) / Improving Places Select Commission (IPSC) Scrutiny Review into attachments to street lighting columns. 

The review was commissioned following a Notice of Motion approved by Full Council in April 2026 concerning the impact of structural testing requirements on community initiatives such as hanging baskets, festive decorations, remembrance displays and CCTV installations. The review examined the balance between public safety requirements and the financial and operational impact on Parish and Town Councils. Evidence was gathered from officers, Parish Councils, survey responses and examples of practice from other authorities. 

The recommendations sought to establish a clear, proportionate and transparent framework that supported community-led initiatives whilst ensuring the safety and effective management of highway assets.

In moving the report, Councillor Allen thanked OSMB and IPSC for their work and for completing a very thorough review. She welcomed the recommendations, particularly the introduction of a framework that would apply to all and the efforts to improve communication with Parish Council. Councillor Allen explained that the response would be led by herself as Cabinet Member for Communities and Councillor Williams as Cabinet Member for Transport, Jobs and the Local Economy.

Councillor Steele was invited to speak to the report. He thanked officers for their work and for ensuring that the review progressed at pace. Clear information had been provided to the review group which enabled a very positive, cross-party process.

Councillor Williams thanked Scrutiny for their work on this matter. He also reiterated that there were no restrictions relating to the installation of poppies on street lighting columns. The Leader confirmed that incorrect information had been given out by the Council on this matter and he wanted to be clear on this as Remembrance Sunday approached – there were no restrictions on poppies.

Resolved:

 

1.    That Cabinet receives the recommendations listed below, as approved by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board:

  1. Approve amendments to the Highway Asset Management Plan to incorporate a comprehensive framework for attachments to lighting columns and associated highway assets, setting out requirements relating to permitted and prohibited attachments, risk-based approval arrangements, structural testing and retesting requirements, applicant responsibilities, and enforcement provisions. The framework should apply consistently to all users of street lighting columns, including the Council, Parish and Town Councils, contractors and third parties.

  2. Approve the development and publication of a standalone, publicly accessible Street Lighting Column Attachments Guidance Document, in consultation with Parish and Town Councils, to provide clear and practical guidance on the application of the Highway Asset Management Plan framework, including attachment classifications, approval processes, testing requirements, responsibilities, communication arrangements, and practical examples of acceptable and unacceptable attachments.

  3. Establish formal consultation, communication and engagement arrangements with Parish and Town Councils, including consultation on future policy changes, testing programmes and charging arrangements, together with sufficient advance notice of any financial implications to enable effective budget planning, procurement and decision-making.

  4. Establish clear categories for street lighting column attachments, identifying which attachments are permitted without testing, permitted subject to approval and structural testing, or prohibited, and publish consistent standards for structural testing, assessment criteria, retesting intervals, validity periods and maximum permissible loading thresholds where appropriate.

  5. Continues to coordinate structural testing arrangements on a borough wide basis where appropriate and considers longer-term funding, procurement and cost-sharing arrangements to minimise administrative burdens and secure value for money for Parish and Town Councils whilst maintaining compliance with relevant safety standards.

  6. Ensures arrangements are developed to support the continuation of community display schemes where street lighting columns are unable to safely accommodate attachments, including consideration of alternative display solutions, targeted asset replacement where appropriate, the use of structural testing outcomes to identify trends, inform the Council’s future investment priorities, replacement programmes and wider asset management decisions.

  7. That the service engages in meaningful discussions with interested parties including Parish Councils, seeking to install displays on street lighting columns, with the aim of reaching a shared understanding regarding the timescales and process for replacing damaged or missing columns, and to explore opportunities to facilitate timely installation where feasible.

  8. Strengthen the enforcement framework for unauthorised attachments by establishing clear compliance procedures and, where legally permissible, implementing arrangements for the recovery of costs incurred in the removal of unauthorised installations, and reviews the effectiveness of the new arrangements within 12 months of implementation, including consideration of feedback from Parish and Town Councils, testing outcomes and enforcement activity, with the findings reported to the relevant Scrutiny Board.

 

2.    That Cabinet formally considers its response to the above recommendations within two months of its receipt, in accordance with the Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rules.

3.    That in responding to these recommendations, it is requested that Cabinet’s response should identify the proposed actions, responsible officer(s), success measures and target completion dates for each recommendation.

Supporting documents: