Agenda item

Maintained Schools Long Term Maintenance Plan (LTMP) Update

To receive an update on the development of the Maintained Schools Long-Term Maintenance Plan (LTMP), including the approach and protocols that will underpin the plan and how future maintenance priorities will link with wider education considerations, such as school sufficiency and/or expansion requirements and academisation.

 

Minutes:

This item provided an update on the development of the Maintained Schools Long-Term Maintenance Plan (LTMP).

 

The Chair welcomed to the meeting Councillor Cusworth, Cabinet Member for Children’s and Young People’s Services and Kevin Fisher, Service Director for Property and Facilities Services.

 

The Chair invited the Cabinet Member to introduce the report, during which the following points were highlighted:

 

·      The update outlined a planned approach to maintaining school buildings across the borough. A comprehensive survey was underway to assess the condition of school premises and to prioritise investment based on risk, educational need, and value for money.

·      The primary objective was to ensure that school buildings remained safe, warm, and dry, while minimising disruption to children's education and learning wherever possible.

 

The Chair invited the Service Director for Property and Facilities Services to deliver the presentation, during which the following points were noted:

 

Developing a Long-Term Maintenance Plan-

 

·       Work was underway to develop a planned, evidence-led approach to maintaining schools and managing the maintained school estate. At this stage, the long-term maintenance plan had not yet been developed, as condition and asset verification surveys were currently being undertaken. The presentation outlined why this work was required, how the evidence base was being established, the proposed prioritisation principles, and the next steps.

·       The local authority was responsible for seventeen maintained educational settings, comprising of thirteen maintained schools, three maintained nurseries and one pupil referral unit.

·       The Department for Education provided an annual School Condition Allocation to support capital investment across maintained schools. For 2026/27, the available programme funding totalled £1.679 million, comprising £728,000 for the current financial year and £951,000 carried forward from previous financial years.

·       Schools retained the responsibility for routine repairs, maintenance, servicing and day-to-day premises management through their delegated budgets.

·       The role of the local authority was to understand and prioritise major condition and lifecycle investment requirements across the maintained estate. An example was provided where the replacement of individual roof tiles would ordinarily be the responsibility of the school. However, where a full roof replacement was required, this would constitute a major capital investment and would be funded either through Department for Education capital funding or local authority resources, depending upon the priority and level of need.

Building the Evidence Base-

 

·       While the Department for Education undertook surveys relating to the condition of school buildings, these assessments were high-level and did not provide the level of detail required to identify specific maintenance needs within individual buildings. Historically, the local authority's approach to school maintenance had been largely reactive, focusing on addressing failures and urgent defects. Examples were provided of schools currently requiring roof replacements, some of which may have been avoidable had intervention occurred at an earlier stage. At present, there was no complete validated picture of compliance across the maintained estate, or a comprehensive understanding of future lifecycle and capital investment requirements.

·       To address this, the service was undertaking detailed, in-person surveys across all maintained schools. These surveys would also consider opportunities to reduce carbon emissions and improve energy efficiency, through measures such as solar panels, air source heat pumps and more efficient boiler systems. Once completed, the surveys would support a transition from a reactive and fragmented approach to a planned, strategic and evidence-led approach. This would establish a consistent baseline for assessing risk, support more effective medium and long-term planning, enhance financial forecasting and minimise disruption to schools.

 

Survey Methodology and Prioritisation-

 

·       The first stage of the process would involve surveying buildings to verify assets, establish their condition and identifying likely requirements for intervention, repair or replacement.

·       The second stage would involve validating the information collected through quality assurance processes, to ensure that the data would be accurate and fit for purpose.

·       The third stage would involve assessing condition, compliance, lifecycle and operational risks, enabling a comprehensive understanding of the estate and the impact of any required works.

·       The final stage would focus on planning and prioritisation. A survey finding alone would not determine who would be responsible for funding any identified works. The nature of the work would be assessed to determine whether it would constitute routine repair and maintenance, which would remain the responsibility of the school, or capital expenditure, which may be funded through other sources. Identifying future requirements would enable schools and the local authority to plan investment and funding more effectively.

·       As previously outlined, the Department for Education provided a School Condition Allocation to the local authority, as the responsible body, to support priority capital investment across the maintained school estate. This funding was separate from the schools delegated revenue budgets, with the schools remaining responsible for routine repairs, maintenance and servicing.

·       The local authority was also engaging with the Department for Education to explore opportunities for additional funding once the survey work had been completed.

·       Officers were working closely with Children's and Young People's Services to understand future demand for school places. This would help ensure that investment decisions align with projected pupil numbers and that capital funding would be directed towards schools where demand was expected to remain stable or increase, rather than settings where pupil numbers may significantly decline.

Next Steps-

 

·       The next steps would be to complete and validate the surveys, bring together the property data alongside educational priorities and requirements, and develop a prioritised long-term maintenance plan.

·       Once developed, the draft plan, including identified requirements, proposed programmes of work, sequencing and timescales, would be presented through the appropriate governance arrangements, before being submitted to Cabinet for consideration.

The Chair thanked the officer for the presentation and invited questions from Members. During the discussion, the following points were noted:

 

·      The rate of academisation had slowed and the current Government was placing less emphasis on schools joining academy trusts.

·      The condition surveys were expected to be completed and validated during the first quarter of 2027/28. These surveys formed part of a wider programme of condition surveys across the Council’s estate, with schools and care facilities being prioritised. Surveys would also be undertaken on academy buildings. Whilst the Council was not responsible for funding repairs and maintenance within academies, it retained an interest as the freeholder and was required to ensure that leased buildings remained safe and compliant. The programme also included surveys of fifteen PFI schools.

·      In relation to the prioritisation of maintenance and repair works, Members were advised that health, safety and safeguarding considerations would carry the greatest priority. Any issue that presented a risk to pupils, staff or members of the public would be treated as a priority.

·      Officers explained that the Council had a strong understanding of statutory compliance across much of the maintained school estate, including areas such as electrical testing, legionella management and asbestos registers. The principal gaps related to schools where compliance services were not provided directly by the Council. These schools were being prioritised for survey work and were subject to targeted engagement, including site visits and direct contact, to ensure compliance requirements could be evidenced.

·      Members were informed that significant investment had been made in asset management systems as part of the wider review of the Council’s estate. This included the procurement of a new Computer-Aided Facilities Management (CAFM) system, which would work alongside the CIPFA asset management database to provide improved oversight of the estate.

·      It was noted that Property Services would work closely with Children and Young People's Services, business managers and headteachers to understand educational requirements, operational priorities and potential impacts of planned maintenance works. Engagement would also take place with SEND leads to ensure that SEND sufficiency requirements were fully understood and considered. Wherever possible, maintenance works would be scheduled during the six-week summer holiday period to minimise disruption.

·      Members heard that the prioritisation framework would focus on ensuring that buildings were safe, compliant, and maintained to a standard that was safe, warm and dry.

·      Following the consolidation of property-related functions into a single service area, a review of health and safety and compliance arrangements across the Council’s estate had been undertaken. This review, informed through engagement with schools, CYPS colleagues, business managers and headteachers, identified that whilst awareness of asbestos-related responsibilities was generally strong, understanding of wider statutory compliance duties was less consistent. In response, an A-to-Z Compliance Guide had been developed collaboratively with school leaders and CYPS colleagues. The guide clearly set out compliance requirements, responsibilities and available support, and had been well received through the Headteachers Forum.

·      Although much of the work aligned with climate change and net zero objectives, the surveys were also assessing broader issues relating to energy management, sustainability, heating and ventilation. Potential measures under consideration included enhanced insulation, solar panels and heat pump technology, which could contribute to both decarbonisation goals and improved temperature management within school buildings. These considerations would be incorporated into the Long-Term Maintenance Plan in collaboration with the Council’s Climate Change Team and schools.

·      Members noted that the principles of the Long-Term Maintenance Plan would be presented to Cabinet for consideration. The proposed approach included the development of a five-year programme of long-term maintenance and planned preventative maintenance across the Council’s estate, supported by an annual review and refresh. This would provide updates on completed works, revised priorities and projects carried forward.

·      Officers advised that annual reports would be submitted to Cabinet detailing delivery, expenditure and progress against objectives. It was further agreed that the annual update would be presented to the Improving Places Select Commission, with Members of the Improving Lives Select Commission invited to participate in consideration of matters relating to the school estate.

·      It was reported that procurement arrangements were being reviewed to support more efficient delivery of maintenance programmes. Consideration was being given to the appointment of a smaller number of contractors through longer-term contractual arrangements, with the aim of improving value for money, strengthening delivery capacity and increasing responsiveness during peak periods, particularly over the summer holidays.

·      Members were advised that effective contract management would be critical to ensuring works were delivered on time and with minimal disruption. Whilst classroom closures would be avoided wherever possible, urgent health and safety or compliance works may occasionally require temporary closures, with arrangements agreed directly with affected schools.

·      It was emphasised that ongoing engagement with schools would ensure maintenance programmes were planned around operational requirements, including mock examinations and examination periods, to minimise disruption to teaching and learning.

 

Resolved:- That the Improving Lives Select Commission:

 

1)     Considered and accepted the update provided.

2)     Requested that a further update on Long-Term Maintenance Planning, be presented to the Improving Places Select Commission, with members of the Improving Lives Select Commission invited to attend.

Supporting documents: