Agenda item

Intrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse Strategy Update

To receive an update on the draft Intrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse Strategy. Including why the Strategy is needed, the key priorities, expected outcomes, the delivery and assurance measures and potential risks.

Minutes:

This item provided an update on the development of the draft Intrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse Strategy 2027- 2030.

 

The Chair welcomed to the meeting Councillor Cusworth, Cabinet Member for Children’s and Young People’s Services, Anna Sedgwick, Detective Superintendent at South Yorkshire Police, Gemma Cross, Head of Quality, Governance and Assurance at The Rotherham NHS Foundation Trust, Vicky Chew, Interim Head of Safeguarding and Darren Downs, Independent Scrutineer.

 

The Chair invited the Cabinet Member to introduce the report, during which the following points were highlighted:

 

·      The development of the draft strategy was not intended to suggest that child sexual abuse was not already being identified, addressed and responded to effectively within Rotherham. Tackling child sexual abuse remained a significant element of the wider safeguarding framework and partnership response.

·      The purpose of the proposed strategy was to strengthen existing arrangements, by providing child sexual abuse with greater strategic visibility and focus, whilst maintaining clear links with, but distinct from, the Child Exploitation Strategy.

·      Earlier in the year, The Centre for Expertise on Child Sexual Abuse presented to the Rotherham Safeguarding Children’s Partnership (RSCP), on the findings of the national review into child sexual abuse. The presentation reinforced the importance of ensuring that children's voices were heard, recognising the signs that children may be exhibiting, and understanding the wide range of contexts in which child sexual abuse could occur. It was emphasised that the development of the strategy was intended to build upon the strong safeguarding arrangements already in place and further enhance the partnership's ability to prevent, identify and respond to child sexual abuse.

 

The Chair invited the Independent Scrutineer to speak on the update, during which the following points were noted:

 

·      The development of a dedicated Child Sexual Abuse Strategy was informed by the findings of the national review into child sexual abuse, published following work undertaken during 2024 and 2025. The review highlighted significant national challenges in identifying, understanding and responding to child sexual abuse and noted that over a five-year period, more than 130 safeguarding reviews considered by the National Child Safeguarding Practice Review Panel had involved elements of child sexual abuse, including intrafamilial abuse.

·      There was currently no single national definition of intrafamilial child sexual abuse, nor a consistent crime category or recording framework, this created challenges in understanding the scale and nature of the issue both locally and nationally. The review made several recommendations aimed at improving understanding, oversight and responses to child sexual abuse across safeguarding partnerships and government agencies.

·      As part of the annual review of the RSCP priorities, existing strategies were reaching the end of their three-year cycle. It was agreed across the partnership that child exploitation would remain a key priority for Rotherham, due to the continued importance of safeguarding activity in this area. There had been significant progress achieved through the Neglect Strategy, which would transition into ongoing oversight through the Practice, Performance and Learning Group, this would ensure continued monitoring and improvement.

·      Child Sexual Abuse had been identified as a strategic partnership priority; to support this, a dedicated strategy and action plan were being developed to provide a framework for partners to work collectively to address the challenges associated with child sexual abuse.

·      Officers highlighted the complexity of the issue, noting that a significant proportion of nationally reported child sexual abuse cases involved peer-on-peer abuse, often involving young people of a similar age. However, evidence from the national review indicated that intrafamilial child sexual abuse, presented some of the greatest risks of harm to children and was often the most difficult form of abuse to identify, disclose and address. It was proposed that the first year of the strategy would place a particular focus on intrafamilial child sexual abuse to strengthen local understanding, identification and intervention, in response to the heightened risks associated with this form of harm.

The Chair invited the Interim Head of Safeguarding to deliver the presentation, during which the following points were noted:

 

Why the Intrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse Strategy was needed-

 

·       The strategy, developed through the Rotherham Safeguarding Children's Partnership, brought together key safeguarding partners to prevent, identify and respond to child sexual abuse. The strategy had originally been developed to address child sexual abuse in its broadest sense. However, as the partnership examined national evidence, local intelligence and learning from safeguarding reviews, particular concerns regarding abuse occurring within families were identified. As a result, the partnership agreed that intrafamilial child sexual abuse would be a particular focus during the initial years of implementation.

·       National evidence demonstrated that child sexual abuse was more prevalent and more hidden than statutory service data suggested. Research estimated that only around one in eight children experiencing sexual abuse would come to the attention of professionals at the time the abuse was occurring.

·       In relation to abuse within families, national police-recorded data highlighted that 26% of offences where the relationship between victim and perpetrator had been recorded were familial. Of those intrafamilial cases where the victim's age was known, 44% of victims were under 10 years old.

·       Locally, sexual abuse featured in 4.5% of Section 47 investigations and 2.6% of Child Protection Plans during 2025/26. Whilst local data provided an indication of the children being identified through safeguarding processes, it did not capture the number of children who remained unidentified. This represented a key challenge that the strategy sought to address. The evidence reinforced that children, particularly younger children experiencing abuse within their families, may have been unable to disclose what was happening due to a range of factors, including fear or an inability to understand or articulate their experiences.

The Four Strategy Priorities-

 

·       The partnership recognised the need to improve its ability to identify signs of abuse, share information and take appropriate safeguarding action, rather than relying solely on disclosures from children. The strategy was organised around four key priorities, each with a lead partner and shared responsibility for delivery:

o   Develop, led by the Safeguarding Children's Partnership. This priority focused on strengthening professional knowledge, confidence and practice, including the development of a clearer multi-agency pathway.

o   Prevent and Identify, led by Public Health. This priority sought to move beyond responding to abuse once it had been identified. The partnership aimed to improve understanding across schools, universal services and wider communities so that concerns could be recognised at an earlier stage.

o   Investigate and Disrupt, led by South Yorkshire Police. This priority focused on effective joint working, information sharing and the management of risks posed by adults who may harm children. A key principle was that safeguarding action should continue even where there was no prosecution or criminal justice outcome.

o   Support and Recover, led by health partners. This priority recognised the need for timely, appropriate and compassionate support for children and families, including therapeutic and emotional support.

·       It was noted that the four priorities were interconnected. The ambition was not simply to improve how individual agencies responded, but to create a more coordinated safeguarding system around children and families.

Five Outcomes by 2030-

 

  • By 2030, the partnership sought to achieve five key outcomes:
    • More children would be identified and protected at an earlier stage.
    • Fewer children would experience repeat harm.
    • Children and families would have improved access to support to aid recovery.
    • There would be stronger identification and management of individuals who posed a sexual risk to children.
    • Children's voices and experiences would influence how services were designed and delivered.
  • Members were advised that success would not necessarily be reflected in a reduction in referrals, particularly during the early stages of implementation. Increased awareness and professional confidence could result in more children being identified who had previously remained hidden. The true measure of success would be whether children were safer, whether harm was prevented or addressed earlier, and whether children and families received the support they required.

Delivery and Assurance-

  • The strategy had a clear structure for delivery and accountability. A multi-agency delivery group, chaired by the Rotherham NHS Foundation Trust, would oversee progress and would be supported by two working groups focusing on child sexual abuse and investigation and disruption.
  • Progress would be reported to the Safeguarding Children's Partnership Executive every two months, with an annual summary provided through the Partnership's Annual Report.
  • The partnership would monitor a range of measures, including identification rates, repeat harm, timeliness of interventions, access to support and feedback from children and families. Consideration would also be given to whether particular groups of children faced additional barriers to identification or service access. This would support understanding not only of whether actions had been completed, but also whether the strategy was making a meaningful difference.

Potential Risks-

  • The partnership recognised the need to ensure that its response did not inadvertently cause further distress to children through repeated questioning or poorly coordinated interventions. It was also acknowledged that some children, including boys, disabled children and children from ethnic minority communities, could face additional barriers to recognition and support. The partnership therefore sought to raise awareness sensitively, recognising the stigma and complexity that could surround abuse within families.
  • It was recognised that safeguarding could not rest solely with social workers, police officers or health professionals. Schools had a particularly important role due to their regular contact with children and their ability to recognise changes in behaviour or presentation, provide trusted adults and raise safeguarding concerns. There was also a wider role for voluntary organisations, faith groups, sports clubs and community networks. Members were encouraged to support the partnership by identifying opportunities to share safeguarding messages, understand barriers to engagement and reach families who may otherwise have limited access to information. The partnership aimed to build awareness and confidence across communities so that more adults could recognise signs of concern and know where to seek advice. Ultimately, the ambition was to ensure that children did not have to carry the responsibility of disclosing abuse themselves.

The Chair thanked the officer for the presentation and invited questions from Members. During the discussion, the following points were noted:

  • In relation to the five outcomes, no baseline measures were currently available. Whilst some national measures existed, there was limited benchmarking information available. The first step would be to develop a fuller understanding of the wider picture. Child sexual abuse offences could be recorded under multiple crime categories, and recording systems did not consistently capture information relating to perpetrators or their relationship to victims. The partnership aimed to establish relevant benchmark data by the end of the first year of implementation. Members were advised that the independent scrutineer had not recommended setting specific targets until there was a clearer understanding of the wider picture.
  • In relation to equal access and risk management, Members were advised that wider partnership work was already underway. Boys, disabled children and children from ethnic minority backgrounds were disproportionately represented in relation to exploitation. This work included professional training, awareness-raising activities and efforts to improve access to services. Workforce confidence was identified as a key factor, as these groups could present differently and experience abuse in different ways. National data indicated that disabled children were twice as likely to experience sexual harm, whilst 5% of victims of child sexual abuse were boys.
  • Members were advised that every school had a Designated Safeguarding Lead responsible for training staff on safeguarding procedures and ensuring awareness of the Multi-Agency Safeguarding Hub (MASH).
  • Training across the partnership and associated agencies was reported to be well attended, regularly refreshed and continuously developed in response to emerging research, learning and an evolving understanding of risk, vulnerability and indicators of harm.
  • National research highlighted that services had traditionally relied on children disclosing intrafamilial sexual abuse, despite it being a largely hidden form of harm. As a result, there was a strong focus on equipping professionals, partners and communities to recognise behavioural indicators and presentations that may signify abuse. Members noted that the borough benefited from strong schools with a detailed understanding of their pupils.
  • The Centre of Expertise Child Sexual Abuse Pathway Tool was highlighted as a national resource available to parents, Designated Safeguarding Leads, teachers and other trusted adults. The tool provided guidance on recognising signs of abuse and initiating supportive conversations. Members were advised that the Prevent and Identify priority would be led by Public Health and would involve work across families, schools, children and the youth justice system to raise awareness in a sensitive and meaningful manner. Family Hubs would also continue to promote healthy relationships through their outreach and engagement work.
  • It was noted that child sexual abuse could occur between peers, including within school settings. National research suggested that disclosures were often made to friends before being reported to a teacher or other trusted adult. The Evolve Team worked closely with Year 5 and Year 6 pupils across schools on this subject area. The partnership had presented to the Children and Young People's Partnership Board and was engaging with Police Cadets to establish a group of young scrutineers. This group would help inform awareness campaigns, messaging and service development. The Voice and Influence Team had also been actively involved in co-producing child-friendly information materials, including website content and publications. In addition, the partnership was establishing a Parents' Group which would include individuals with lived experience, to support the co-production of resources for parents and carers. The Neglect Delivery Group, including representatives from the Elective Home Education Team, had also been involved in reviewing and refreshing relevant publicity materials such as leaflets.
  • The service agreed to consider how information could be effectively communicated to children with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND), children educated outside of school settings and other groups less likely to disclose concerns through traditional school-based channels. A further update would be provided to the Commission on the findings and proposed next steps.
  • Members were advised that Rotherham benefited from a stable workforce within this area of practice. Staff were managed with emotional intelligence and supported through a well-established supervision framework. Three Practice Consultants within the Safeguarding Service were also available to provide additional support when required.
  • The service aspired to develop alternative reporting mechanisms for children and young people, including potential digital solutions. Consideration would be given to this during the lifetime of the strategy, and feedback would be provided to the Commission in due course.
  • The I Wanted People to Notice Report was identified as a key document for improving services through engagement with survivors of child sexual abuse. The report highlighted that survivors frequently attempted to communicate what was happening to them; therefore, partnership training would focus on helping practitioners recognise and respond to those signs and signals. Members were also advised that education relating to healthy relationships formed part of the Personal, Social, Health and Economical (PHSE) curriculum from primary school onwards.
  • Elected Members were encouraged to contact the Multi-Agency Safeguarding Hub (MASH) if they had safeguarding concerns or required advice regarding specific situations.
  • It was explained that the management of adults who posed safeguarding risks could continue regardless of whether a prosecution was secured. This could include the use of Multi-Agency Public Protection Arrangements (MAPPA), Sexual Risk Orders, the Child Sex Offender Disclosure Scheme, rehabilitation programmes, bail conditions and electronic monitoring. Members were advised that the criminal justice system operated to a high evidential threshold and that not all cases resulted in prosecution. In some instances, court proceedings could take between two and three years following arrest.
  • The partnership was developing a joint protocol between South Yorkshire Police and Children's and Young People’s Services, to strengthen information sharing arrangements in support of safeguarding children, young people and wider family members.
  • Members noted that information sharing was inherently complex and required professionals to consider potential risks arising from disclosure. However, updated statutory guidance under Working Together to Safeguard Children, had lowered the threshold for sharing information where safeguarding concerns existed. Since September 2026, agencies had been under a duty to share information where it was reasonably believed to relate to the safety or welfare of a child.
  • Any individual subject to investigation for child sexual abuse offences prior to court proceedings, would undergo a full risk assessment through the police custody process, including pre-release risk assessments and associated risk management plans. Where individuals had contact with children or young people, Children's Services would be involved, and appropriate support arrangements would be put in place.
  • Members were advised that the Partnership Executive Group was responsible for overseeing the delivery of the strategy and monitoring performance outcomes. Executive Group members were expected to challenge one another constructively and collectively hold partner agencies to account.
  • Assurances were provided that the work relating to healthy relationships encompassed child-on-child abuse occurring within households. It was advised that whilst the title of the strategy might not explicitly reflect every type of abuse covered, the strategy would address the full spectrum of child-on-child harm.

 

Resolved:- That the Improving Lives Select Commission:

1)    Considered and accepted the need for the strategy, including its priorities, intended outcomes and proposed delivery arrangements.

2)    Requested that a further progress update be presented to the Commission during the next municipal year.

3)    Requested that consideration be given to how relevant information and opportunities will be communicated and made accessible to all children and young people, with particular regard to children and young people with special educational needs and disabilities, and those who are electively home educated.

4)    Requested that consideration be given to alternative reporting mechanisms that may be more accessible and appropriate for children and young people.

 

 

 

Supporting documents: