Agenda item

Investing in our Community Facilities - Update report

 

To consider the update on the Community Facilities Programme, setting out completed improvements, remaining works and the funding position.

 

Minutes:

At the Chair’s invitation, Judith Badger, Executive Director of Corporate Services, reminded members that the Council had previously allocated £600,000 through the capital programme to improve community buildings that had fallen into disrepair or, in some cases, had become unavailable for community use. Members were advised that additional external funding had subsequently been secured, increasing the available investment to approximately £1.2 million. Officers explained that this additional funding would enable a greater scope of work to be delivered across the programme, although some projects would continue into the following financial year to ensure all available grant funding was utilised effectively.

 

Presenting the detailed update, Kevin Fisher, Service Director for Property and Facilities Services, reported that the original programme had focused on five facilities: Oaklea Retreat, The Meeting Place, Artworks, the community building operated by Clifton Learning Partnership and Black Hut. Since the programme commenced, two further facilities had been added: the United Multicultural Centre and the Shiloh Centre. Members were informed that improvement works at Oaklea Retreat, The Meeting Place, Artworks, Clifton Learning Partnership and the United Multicultural Centre had all been completed. Work at the Shiloh Centre remained at an earlier stage, with officers working alongside users of the building to determine the precise requirements, which were expected to include roof replacement and internal refurbishment works.

 

Attention was given to the future of the Black Hut, which officers described as the catalyst for the wider programme. Members heard that extensive engagement had been undertaken with community groups, ward members and partner organisations to determine the future requirements of the site. Officers reported that design work was nearing completion and that proposals were being developed to demolish the existing building and replace it with a new modular facility. It was explained that the proposed development remained within the overall programme budget and that discussions were taking place with other Council services to maximise community use of the new facility, including opportunities to incorporate additional community services such as library provision. Officers advised that feedback received on completed schemes had generally been positive.

 

The Chair invited members of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) to raise questions and queries.

 

Councillor Yasseen sought clarification regarding the criteria used to select buildings for inclusion within the programme, particularly the two facilities that had been added after the original programme was approved. Questions were raised regarding how decisions were made about which buildings should receive investment and whether wider considerations relating to community use and accessibility had been considered.

 

In response, Kevin Fisher explained that the Council maintained an ongoing review of its property portfolio and prioritised buildings according to condition, repair requirements and community impact. Officers stated that both the United Multicultural Centre and the Shiloh Centre had come to attention through urgent maintenance issues. The United Multicultural Centre had experienced severe water ingress which affected electrical systems and forced closure of the building, whilst concerns at the Shiloh Centre centred around the building’s physical condition and its importance as a heavily used community facility. In both cases, officers had assessed the urgency of repairs alongside the potential impact on local communities and service delivery before determining priorities.

 

Councillor Yasseen welcomed investment in community buildings but questioned whether sufficient consideration was being given to how facilities were used once refurbished. Concerns were raised that not all buildings within the programme were equally accessible to their local communities and that some facilities had experienced periods of limited use. It was suggested that investment should be linked to stronger expectations regarding community access and utilisation. Further concerns were expressed regarding consultation arrangements and whether all ward members had been fully involved in discussions relating to facilities within their areas.

 

Responding to those concerns, officers acknowledged that stronger links with neighbourhood services would be beneficial and accepted that engagement arrangements could be improved. It was recognised that responsibility for community engagement had sometimes been assumed to sit with neighbourhood teams when a more coordinated approach across services was required. Officers committed to strengthening future engagement with ward members, neighbourhood teams and community stakeholders as additional facilities were considered for investment.

 

Councillor Baggaley concentrated initially on the proposed redevelopment of The Black Hut. Concerns were raised about the timetable for delivery and whether procurement processes might delay implementation, particularly given previous challenges experienced elsewhere within capital programmes. Clarification was sought regarding the current procurement position and the realism of the proposed delivery timescales.

 

Officers advised that demolition works had already entered procurement and that preparations for acquiring the replacement building were well advanced. Members were informed that the proposed replacement would be a high-quality modular building rather than a temporary structure and that existing utility connections would simplify installation. Officers expressed confidence that the proposed timetable remained achievable and that procurement arrangements were progressing as planned.

 

Councillor Baggaley also sought assurance that investment in facilities would lead to long-term community benefit once the physical works had been completed. Questions were asked regarding how community groups would be supported to ensure buildings remained sustainable and well used, particularly in the case of facilities such as The Black Hut that had previously been unavailable.

 

In response, officers explained that the programme extended beyond building refurbishment alone. Alongside physical improvements, work was being undertaken to review governance arrangements, lease arrangements and community outcomes for each facility. Members heard that the Council was working with neighbourhood services and other directorates to identify an organisational sponsor for each building who would act as a key liaison point and help ensure that intended community outcomes were delivered. Officers stated that this wider support package was intended to maximise the long-term value of the Council’s investment.

 

Councillor Baggaley later questioned reported underspends on completed projects, particularly at Oaklea Retreat and The Meeting Place. Clarification was sought regarding whether those underspends reflected reductions in project scope or genuine efficiencies achieved during delivery.

 

Officers explained that early estimates had been developed using high-level building assessments. As design work progressed and more detailed surveys were undertaken with community organisations and stakeholders, project costs had been refined and reduced. The underspends therefore reflected more accurate cost estimates rather than any reduction in the agreed scope of works. Members were also advised that any unspent funding remained available within the overall programme budget to address future requirements or potential cost pressures elsewhere in the programme.

 

Councillor Currie welcomed the programme and highlighted the proposed investment in The Black Hut, emphasising the importance of community-led regeneration within areas experiencing high levels of deprivation. Positive comments were made regarding engagement with residents and neighbourhood teams and the role that investment could play in strengthening community pride and participation. Councillor Currie stressed that communities should be encouraged to take ownership of facilities and develop the skills necessary to manage them successfully in the future.

 

While not raising concerns regarding the programme itself, Councillor Currie emphasised the importance of ensuring that local communities remained actively involved following investment and that facilities continued to be supported through community development and capacity-building work.

 

The Chair sought further information regarding how facilities would be promoted to a wider range of community groups once improvement works had been completed. Concern was expressed that buildings should serve the broader community rather than being used by a limited number of organisations. The Chair also asked whether future leasing arrangements would be used to provide greater security and support opportunities for community organisations seeking external funding.

 

In response, officers explained that promotion and utilisation of community facilities would require close collaboration between neighbourhood teams, local groups, ward members and the voluntary sector. Existing community networks and organisations such as VAR were expected to play an important role in increasing awareness and encouraging wider community participation. Officers emphasised that lease arrangements formed a significant part of the programme and confirmed that work was underway to review lease terms, governance structures and responsibilities. Members were informed that longer-term leases, typically in the region of 60 to 65 years, often enabled community organisations to secure external funding and therefore strengthened their long-term sustainability.

 

Throughout the discussion, members welcomed the progress made through the community facilities programme and recognised the significant scale of investment that had been secured. The debate focused on ensuring that investment delivered long-term community benefits, the importance of meaningful engagement with ward members and local communities, and the need to ensure that refurbished facilities were fully utilised and supported by appropriate management and governance arrangements. Officers acknowledged the value of strengthening engagement processes and emphasised that the programme was intended not only to improve physical buildings but also to create sustainable and accessible community assets.

 

Resolved That: The Overview and Scrutiny Management Board:

 

1.    Considered and commented on progress in delivering the Community Facilities Programme, including completed works, the inclusion of Shiloh Centre and United Multicultural Centre, and the remaining works and funding position set out in this report.

Supporting documents: