Report from the Executive Director of Corporate Services.
Recommendations
That Cabinet:
1. Note the current General Fund Revenue Budget forecast overspend of £2.9m.
2. Note the updated position of the Capital Programme.
3. Approve the capital budget variations as detailed in Section 2.17 of the report.
4. Note early payment of £3.052m grant from the Transport for City Regions (TCR) fund, as detailed in section 2.18.5 of the report.
5. Note the allocation of City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement (CRSTS) Revenue Fund grant from South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) as detailed in 2.24 and delegate the decision to allocate and spend all future tranches to the Service Director of Planning, Regeneration and Transport in consultation with the Section 151 Officer and the Cabinet Member for Transport, Jobs and the Local Economy.
Minutes:
At the Chair’s invitiation, Judith Badger, Executive Director of Corporate Services, introduced the report and advised that the previously forecast overspend of £5.9 million had reduced to £2.9 million. This improvement had been achieved primarily through work to maximise the use of grant funding, reserves and other available resources, together with ongoing efforts across services to contain expenditure. It was emphasised that although the position had improved significantly, further work remained necessary to address the remaining overspend, with social care pressures continuing to be the principal driver of financial challenges.
Rob Mahon, Service Director of Financial Services, provided a detailed overview of the report. It was explained that the £3 million improvement since July had resulted from a financial exercise undertaken across the Council to maximise external funding opportunities, review grant allocations and challenge service forecasts. Attention had been given to identifying where grant funding could be used to offset existing expenditure and to reviewing budget forecasts to ensure they reflected realistic spending expectations based on previous trends and current delivery plans. Examples were provided, including the over-65s swimming initiative, where actual demand had been lower than anticipated, generating savings while still delivering the intended outcomes. The Board was advised that directorate pressures remained significant, particularly within social care services, although treasury management savings and lower borrowing requirements were helping to offset those pressures. The report also outlined the implications of early receipt of Transport for City Regions (TCR) funding and the allocation of City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement (CRSTS) revenue funding.
The Chair invited members of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) to raise questions and queries. During the discussion, members focused primarily on workforce pressures, social care costs, treasury management savings, Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) pressures, transport funding and the Council’s wider ability to manage financial risks.
Councillor Keenan sought further information regarding the overspend within Adult Care, Housing and Public Health, particularly the contribution made by agency staffing and overtime costs. Clarification was requested on the measures being taken to address those pressures, whether recruitment efforts had been successful in filling vacancies and the extent to which staffing challenges remained unresolved. In response, officers explained that agency expenditure was concentrated within the Council’s in-house adult care residential provision. Significant recruitment campaigns had already reduced agency dependence, and work was continuing to strengthen permanent staffing levels. Officers advised that future plans included the development of an internal staff bank, similar to NHS arrangements, allowing additional hours to be covered by existing employees rather than external agency workers. It was also noted that regulatory requirements around safe staffing levels limited the Council’s ability to reduce expenditure immediately in these services.
Councillor Keenan also queried an underspend within Public Health arising from staff vacancies, noting the apparent contrast with staffing pressures elsewhere in the organisation. Concerns were raised regarding any service implications that might result from those vacancies. Officers explained that the Public Health underspend reflected normal staff turnover rather than a deliberate decision to hold posts vacant. Vacancies had arisen through employees leaving the authority and the resulting gap before replacement staff were recruited. It was confirmed that there was no recruitment freeze within Public Health and no intentional reduction in staffing capacity.
Councillor Yasseen revisited a theme raised at previous meetings concerning the significant underspend reported within central services, particularly treasury management savings. Information was sought regarding the sustainability of those savings, whether the approach represented a recurring feature of the Council’s financial management strategy and how long such savings could realistically continue. Officers explained that treasury management savings arose primarily through postponing borrowing until funds were genuinely required and through slippage within the capital programme, which reduced borrowing costs. Members were advised that although treasury management savings had featured regularly in recent years, the specific savings changed annually and depended upon prevailing economic conditions, capital programme delivery and interest rates. Detailed modelling and scenario planning were undertaken to assess sustainability, although officers acknowledged that future economic changes remained outside the Council’s control.
Councillor Yasseen also raised concerns regarding the rapidly increasing DSG deficit and sought a clearer explanation of what the expenditure represented, the factors driving projected growth in the deficit and the implications for the Council. Officers outlined how the deficit related primarily to demand for Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) provision, particularly out-of-borough placements. A sharp increase in Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP) applications had been experienced nationally, which officers attributed partly to uncertainty surrounding future SEND reforms. Members were advised that current indications from Government suggested that 90% of DSG deficits would continue to be funded nationally, although this had not yet been formally confirmed. Officers acknowledged that the scale of the projected deficit was concerning but stressed that Rotherham’s position remained more favourable than that of many authorities nationally.
Further questioning focused on transport funding, particularly the City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement and associated feasibility funding. Councillor Yasseen sought clarification regarding references to underspends, additional funding allocations and how future funding decisions would support road safety schemes that residents regularly raised with ward members. Officers explained the distinction between regional underspends within the wider CRSTS programme and local underspends arising from the withdrawal of the Broome Lane scheme following consultation feedback. It was confirmed that feasibility funding would help develop future transport projects by funding surveys, designs and preparatory work, enabling schemes to be brought forward more effectively. Officers also explained that the future Transport for City Regions programme would provide a separate source of transport investment over the coming years.
Following additional discussion, Councillor Yasseen sought confirmation that the withdrawal of the Broome Lane proposal related specifically to the cycling infrastructure scheme rather than wider road safety measures. Officers confirmed that the underspend arose from the decision not to proceed with the proposed cycling scheme following public consultation, rather than from the cancellation of broader road safety initiatives.
Councillor Currie focused attention on savings arising from staff vacancies across the Council. Reference was made to previous concerns regarding vacancy factors within budgets and whether apparent savings could simply reflect posts remaining unfilled. Information was requested on the total value of vacancy-related savings across directorates and whether those savings formed a significant element of the overall financial position. Officers explained that vacancy-related savings naturally arose through staff turnover during any financial year and were not being driven by instructions to deliberately hold posts vacant. While a specific figure for the overall vacancy-related underspend was not immediately available, officers committed to providing that information following the meeting. It was reiterated that services continued actively recruiting to vacancies where operationally required.
Councillor Baggaley questioned officers regarding the Council’s principal budget pressures and whether any were causing particular concern. Clarification was sought regarding how those pressures were being managed and how officers intended to ensure that financial challenges would not adversely affect outcomes for residents. In response, officers identified Children and Young People’s Services placements and some adult social care pressures as the most significant concerns. However, it was reported that adult social care placements had improved compared with previous years and that substantial attention was being given to managing the remaining pressures. Members were assured that most overspends reflected growing demand for services rather than a reduction in provision and that residents were not currently experiencing detrimental impacts because of the financial position. Officers stressed that more difficult decisions would only become necessary if financial pressures worsened significantly.
Councillor McKiernan expressed concern that some reported savings appeared to arise from projects not progressing as originally intended, rather than from genuine efficiencies. Concerns were raised that, were the Council able to deliver all planned activity exactly as budgeted, the underlying financial position might appear significantly worse. Councillor McKiernan specifically sought clarification regarding future funding from the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA), including whether devolved funding arrangements represented either an opportunity or a financial risk. Officers explained that SYMCA would increasingly move towards funding derived from business rates and income tax growth rather than specific grant streams, providing greater freedom and flexibility. However, this approach would also expose SYMCA to economic risks similar to those faced by local authorities. Officers advised that the Council remained actively engaged in discussions with SYMCA to ensure that future arrangements did not adversely affect Rotherham’s funding position.
During the debate, John Edwards provided assurance that performance information was continually monitored alongside financial performance. While acknowledging some delays within the capital programme, it was reported that operational performance data across key services did not indicate any significant deterioration that would suggest residents were receiving reduced service standards because of financial pressures.
The Chair also sought clarification regarding the impact of rising inflation and fuel costs on Council budgets. Officers advised that fuel-related pressures within transport and waste services remained manageable. Energy costs had increased by approximately £300,000 during the financial year, although the Council’s advance purchasing strategy had successfully protected it from much of the volatility experienced in wider energy markets.
Towards the conclusion of the discussion, the Chair asked how officers intended to eliminate the remaining £2.9 million overspend and restore a balanced budget position by year-end. Officers confirmed that extensive work was underway with Executive Directors, Service Directors and budget holders to identify opportunities to reduce non-essential spending, maximise income and review vacant positions where doing so would not adversely affect service delivery. It was stressed that the Council had a strong track record of improving forecast outturn positions during the second half of the financial year and that officers remained confident that the final position would improve further before year-end.
Resolved: That the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board supported the recommendations that Cabinet:
Further actions that arose from discussions were that:
· The Service Director for Financial Services to provide OSMB members with the total vacancy-related underspend across all directorates contained within the September 2026/27 forecast position, as requested during the meeting.
Supporting documents: