Agenda item

Medium Term Financial Strategy Update

 

Report from the Executive Director of Corporate Services.

 

Recommendation:

 

That Cabinet note the MTFS 2026/27 to 2029/30 update.

 

 

Minutes:

At the Chair’s invitation, Judith Badger, Executive Director of Corporate Services, explained that the report represented a technical update to the Council’s financial planning assumptions rather than a set of final budget proposals. The review reassessed key assumptions that underpinned the Medium-Term Financial Strategy, including funding levels, inflation, demand pressures, income projections, and treasury management forecasts. Members were advised that, when the budget had been approved earlier in the year, the Council had a balanced position for 2027-28 and 2028-29 but faced a projected funding gap of approximately £11 million in 2029-30. Following a reassessment of assumptions and available information, the updated position now showed projected surpluses in the two succeeding years and a significantly reduced gap in 2029-30. Whilst this represented a more favourable position, it was emphasised that any future decisions to utilise apparent surpluses would create recurring costs that would need to be funded in subsequent years. The update therefore established a revised baseline from which future budget decisions would be developed.

 

Presenting the detailed financial position, Rob Mahon, Service Director of Financial Services, outlined how revised assumptions on business rates, council tax collection, inflation, treasury management, and Government funding had altered the Council’s outlook. Members were advised that the Council now projected an underspend of £3.7 million in 2027-28 and £2.2 million in 2028-29, although a significant funding challenge remained in 2029-30. Officers explained that the latter year coincided with the beginning of the next Government spending review period and therefore remained subject to considerable uncertainty. A substantial element of the improved position had arisen from a more favourable outlook for retained business rates, linked both to the ongoing Government operation of the steelworks site and expectations surrounding the delayed Fair Funding Review. Members were also advised that strong council tax and business rates collection performance continued to place the authority in a comparatively robust position. Officers further highlighted the impact of treasury management savings, revised inflation forecasts, and assumptions regarding Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) deficits. It was explained that the Council’s planning assumptions currently reflected Government indications that 90% of future DSG deficits would be funded nationally, whilst local authorities would remain responsible for addressing the remaining proportion.

 

The Chair invited members of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) to raise questions and queries. The ensuing discussion focused on the sustainability of the MTFS assumptions, ongoing demand pressures, treasury management savings, children’s placement costs, housing finances, reserves, and DSG risks.

 

Councillor Baggaley questioned the apparent improvement in the MTFS position and sought clarification on why projected surpluses were emerging despite the overspends and service pressures reported earlier in the financial monitoring report. Information was requested on whether these underlying pressures had been fully reflected within the Medium-Term Financial Strategy. In response, officers explained that some current-year pressures were not expected to continue into future years. For example, pressures within waste management were anticipated to reduce once operational improvement projects had been fully implemented. Home-to-school transport pressures had already been partially accounted for within the MTFS through annual budget increases. Adult social care was reported to be in a stronger position than in previous years, with savings plans progressing and ongoing work aimed at reducing reliance on agency staffing. Officers acknowledged that the most significant unresolved pressure remained within Children and Young People’s Services (CYPS), particularly around placement costs. It was explained that discussions were still ongoing regarding the extent to which those pressures should be reflected in future budgets and that further consideration would form part of the formal budget-setting process.

 

Councillor Baggaley also explored the assumptions underpinning future treasury management savings. Concern was expressed regarding the reliance on savings generated by borrowing strategies and slippage within the capital programme, given the uncertainty associated with those factors. Officers explained that detailed modelling had been undertaken using historical borrowing patterns, capital programme delivery rates, and cash flow forecasts. The Council had accumulated several years of data demonstrating consistent treasury management savings, allowing a higher degree of confidence to be applied to future forecasts. However, officers acknowledged that they could not predict wider economic events, interest rate movements, or global market conditions and that these factors would continue to present risks. It was noted that improved delivery of the capital programme itself would ultimately reduce some treasury management savings, although this would be regarded as a positive outcome because it would indicate successful project delivery.

 

Towards the end of the discussion, Councillor Baggaley returned to the issue of Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) deficits. Clarification was sought regarding how the Council would respond should Government support not materialise at the level currently assumed. Officers explained that the absence of significant Government support would create substantial financial pressures for local authorities nationally. In such circumstances, the Council would be required to draw upon reserves in the short term while undertaking a comprehensive review of its medium-term budget position. Officers stressed that they considered such a scenario unlikely and remained of the view that Government would be unable to transfer the full burden of DSG deficits onto local authorities without significant consequences for the sector.

 

Councillor Currie focused on Children and Young People’s Services and asked whether investment-to-save approaches similar to those implemented previously were being considered to reduce future placement pressures. Specific reference was made to earlier initiatives which had sought to increase local provision and reduce dependency on expensive external placements. Councillor Currie also sought clarification regarding the relationship between the Medium-Term Financial Strategy and the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Business Plan, noting the long-term nature of housing finances and querying whether investment through the HRA could help address wider financial challenges.

 

In response, officers outlined the extensive work underway to increase in-house residential provision within CYPS. Members were advised that additional children’s homes were being developed and that, although progress had been slower than anticipated owing to recruitment difficulties and regulatory requirements, these investments were expected to generate significant future savings by reducing reliance on costly external placements. Officers also explained that other initiatives involving fostering and kinship care arrangements continued to be pursued. Regarding housing finances, members were informed that the HRA and General Fund were legally separate and could not be used to subsidise one another. Whilst both financial plans were developed alongside each other and overseen through similar governance processes, expenditure, and resources within the HRA could not be used to address pressures within the Council’s General Fund budget.

 

Councillor Monk concentrated on the assumptions underpinning the CYPS budget position. Reference was made to statements within the report indicating that no additional budget provision had been made because it was considered achievable to maximise occupancy within the Council’s residential provision. Councillor Monk sought assurance that such assumptions remained compatible with ensuring placements were always in the best interests of children and not solely driven by financial considerations.

 

Officers acknowledged the challenge and explained that placement decisions would continue to be made based on the needs of individual children. Whilst maximising occupancy within Council-run provision would produce significant savings, officers accepted that matching children to appropriate placements would not always align perfectly with available capacity. Nonetheless, the completion and full utilisation of the Council’s residential provision was expected to reduce overall placement costs significantly. Officers further reported that the number of looked-after children had begun to stabilise and that future work would focus on ensuring placements were delivered as cost-effectively as possible without compromising outcomes for children.

 

Councillor Yasseen began by commenting positively on the Council’s financial management over an extended period, particularly in light of major challenges such as austerity measures and the impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic. Whilst recognising the strong financial controls that had been exercised, Councillor Yasseen emphasised that the cumulative loss of funding over many years had inevitably affected service provision and the level of support available to residents. It was suggested that there was value in maintaining transparency with residents regarding those long-term funding pressures and their consequences.

 

Councillor Yasseen then raised concerns about future resilience and emergency planning, particularly considering recent national discussions regarding preparedness for major incidents or disruptions. Questions were asked regarding how the Medium-Term Financial Strategy accounted for potential unforeseen events and whether the Council possessed the financial resilience necessary to respond to severe emergencies affecting residents. In response, officers explained that emergency planning and business continuity arrangements would guide the operational response to such situations. From a financial perspective, the Council’s reserves represented the primary safeguard against major unforeseen risks. Reference was made to the Council’s minimum reserve provision of £25 million, which had been deliberately rebuilt over several years to strengthen resilience. Officers noted that these reserves had enabled the authority to respond effectively during the Covid-19 pandemic and would provide the financial flexibility needed to respond to future emergencies while awaiting any Government support that might become available.

 

Councillor McKiernan questioned the projected use of reserves within the MTFS and sought clarification regarding the apparent reduction in reserve balances during the planning period. Concern was expressed regarding the sustainability of drawing down reserves and how the Council intended to maintain an appropriate level of financial resilience.

 

Officers explained that much of the reserve movement reflected the planned use of recovery grant funding which had been received over a three-year period and deliberately profiled into future budgets. Members were advised that approximately £10 million of recovery grant funding would pass through reserves before being utilised to support the budget position in 2028-29. Additionally, provisions had been included to manage the anticipated impact of DSG accounting changes. Officers reiterated that the Council did not view the use of reserves as a sustainable method of funding ongoing expenditure and confirmed that the long-term intention remained to rebuild reserve balances wherever possible. The position reflected a temporary financial planning mechanism rather than an ongoing reliance on reserves to balance the budget.

 

Throughout the discussion, officers consistently emphasised that the report represented a technical update to the financial baseline rather than a final budget strategy. Whilst members welcomed the improved financial outlook, detailed discussion highlighted continuing concerns regarding CYPS placement costs, DSG pressures, future Government funding arrangements, and the need to maintain adequate reserves. Members were advised that a more comprehensive report setting out detailed budget proposals would be presented to the Board in January 2027 after the provisional local government finance settlement had been received and the budget-setting process had progressed further.

 

Resolved: That the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board supported the recommendations that Cabinet:

  1. Note the MTFS 2026/27 to 2029/30 update.

Supporting documents: