Agenda and draft minutes

Overview and Scrutiny Management Board - Tuesday 10 November 2026 9.00 a.m.

Venue: Council Chamber - Rotherham Town Hall, Moorgate Street, Rotherham, South Yorkshire S60 2TH. View directions

Contact: Barbel Gale, Governance Manager, Tel: 01709 807665 email:  governance@rotherham.gov.uk  The webcast can be viewed at http://www.rotherham.public-i.tv

Items
No. Item

60.

Minutes of meeting Wednesday 7 October 2026 of Overview and Scrutiny Management Board pdf icon PDF 201 KB

 

To consider the minutes of the previous meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board held on 7 October 2026 and to approve them as a true and correct record of the proceedings and to be signed by the Chair.

 

 

 

Minutes:

Resolved: That the Minutes of the meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board held on 7 October 2026 be approved as a true record.

61.

Declarations of Interest

 

To receive declarations of interest from Members in respect of items listed on the agenda.

 

 

Minutes:

No declarations of interest were made.

62.

Questions from Members of the Public and the Press

 

To receive questions relating to items of business on the agenda from members of the public or press who are present at the meeting.

 

 

Minutes:

No questions were received.

63.

Exclusion of the Press and Public

 

To consider whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during consideration of any part of the agenda.

 

 

 

Minutes:

There were no reasons to exclude the press or public.

64.

September 2026-27 Financial Monitoring Report pdf icon PDF 458 KB

 

Report from the Executive Director of Corporate Services.

 

Recommendations

 

That Cabinet:

 

1.    Note the current General Fund Revenue Budget forecast overspend of £2.9m.

 

2.    Note the updated position of the Capital Programme.

 

3.    Approve the capital budget variations as detailed in Section 2.17 of the report.

 

4.    Note early payment of £3.052m grant from the Transport for City Regions (TCR) fund, as detailed in section 2.18.5 of the report.

 

5.    Note the allocation of City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement (CRSTS) Revenue Fund grant from South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) as detailed in 2.24 and delegate the decision to allocate and spend all future tranches to the Service Director of Planning, Regeneration and Transport in consultation with the Section 151 Officer and the Cabinet Member for Transport, Jobs and the Local Economy.

 

 

Additional documents:

Minutes:

At the Chair’s invitiation, Judith Badger, Executive Director of Corporate Services, introduced the report and advised that the previously forecast overspend of £5.9 million had reduced to £2.9 million. This improvement had been achieved primarily through work to maximise the use of grant funding, reserves and other available resources, together with ongoing efforts across services to contain expenditure. It was emphasised that although the position had improved significantly, further work remained necessary to address the remaining overspend, with social care pressures continuing to be the principal driver of financial challenges.

 

Rob Mahon, Service Director of Financial Services, provided a detailed overview of the report. It was explained that the £3 million improvement since July had resulted from a financial exercise undertaken across the Council to maximise external funding opportunities, review grant allocations and challenge service forecasts. Attention had been given to identifying where grant funding could be used to offset existing expenditure and to reviewing budget forecasts to ensure they reflected realistic spending expectations based on previous trends and current delivery plans. Examples were provided, including the over-65s swimming initiative, where actual demand had been lower than anticipated, generating savings while still delivering the intended outcomes. The Board was advised that directorate pressures remained significant, particularly within social care services, although treasury management savings and lower borrowing requirements were helping to offset those pressures. The report also outlined the implications of early receipt of Transport for City Regions (TCR) funding and the allocation of City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement (CRSTS) revenue funding.

 

The Chair invited members of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) to raise questions and queries. During the discussion, members focused primarily on workforce pressures, social care costs, treasury management savings, Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) pressures, transport funding and the Council’s wider ability to manage financial risks.

 

Councillor Keenan sought further information regarding the overspend within Adult Care, Housing and Public Health, particularly the contribution made by agency staffing and overtime costs. Clarification was requested on the measures being taken to address those pressures, whether recruitment efforts had been successful in filling vacancies and the extent to which staffing challenges remained unresolved. In response, officers explained that agency expenditure was concentrated within the Council’s in-house adult care residential provision. Significant recruitment campaigns had already reduced agency dependence, and work was continuing to strengthen permanent staffing levels. Officers advised that future plans included the development of an internal staff bank, similar to NHS arrangements, allowing additional hours to be covered by existing employees rather than external agency workers. It was also noted that regulatory requirements around safe staffing levels limited the Council’s ability to reduce expenditure immediately in these services.

 

Councillor Keenan also queried an underspend within Public Health arising from staff vacancies, noting the apparent contrast with staffing pressures elsewhere in the organisation. Concerns were raised regarding any service implications that might result from those vacancies. Officers explained that the Public Health underspend reflected normal staff turnover rather than a deliberate decision to hold posts vacant.  ...  view the full minutes text for item 64.

65.

Medium Term Financial Strategy Update pdf icon PDF 338 KB

 

Report from the Executive Director of Corporate Services.

 

Recommendation:

 

That Cabinet note the MTFS 2026/27 to 2029/30 update.

 

 

Additional documents:

Minutes:

At the Chair’s invitation, Judith Badger, Executive Director of Corporate Services, explained that the report represented a technical update to the Council’s financial planning assumptions rather than a set of final budget proposals. The review reassessed key assumptions that underpinned the Medium-Term Financial Strategy, including funding levels, inflation, demand pressures, income projections, and treasury management forecasts. Members were advised that, when the budget had been approved earlier in the year, the Council had a balanced position for 2027-28 and 2028-29 but faced a projected funding gap of approximately £11 million in 2029-30. Following a reassessment of assumptions and available information, the updated position now showed projected surpluses in the two succeeding years and a significantly reduced gap in 2029-30. Whilst this represented a more favourable position, it was emphasised that any future decisions to utilise apparent surpluses would create recurring costs that would need to be funded in subsequent years. The update therefore established a revised baseline from which future budget decisions would be developed.

 

Presenting the detailed financial position, Rob Mahon, Service Director of Financial Services, outlined how revised assumptions on business rates, council tax collection, inflation, treasury management, and Government funding had altered the Council’s outlook. Members were advised that the Council now projected an underspend of £3.7 million in 2027-28 and £2.2 million in 2028-29, although a significant funding challenge remained in 2029-30. Officers explained that the latter year coincided with the beginning of the next Government spending review period and therefore remained subject to considerable uncertainty. A substantial element of the improved position had arisen from a more favourable outlook for retained business rates, linked both to the ongoing Government operation of the steelworks site and expectations surrounding the delayed Fair Funding Review. Members were also advised that strong council tax and business rates collection performance continued to place the authority in a comparatively robust position. Officers further highlighted the impact of treasury management savings, revised inflation forecasts, and assumptions regarding Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) deficits. It was explained that the Council’s planning assumptions currently reflected Government indications that 90% of future DSG deficits would be funded nationally, whilst local authorities would remain responsible for addressing the remaining proportion.

 

The Chair invited members of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) to raise questions and queries. The ensuing discussion focused on the sustainability of the MTFS assumptions, ongoing demand pressures, treasury management savings, children’s placement costs, housing finances, reserves, and DSG risks.

 

Councillor Baggaley questioned the apparent improvement in the MTFS position and sought clarification on why projected surpluses were emerging despite the overspends and service pressures reported earlier in the financial monitoring report. Information was requested on whether these underlying pressures had been fully reflected within the Medium-Term Financial Strategy. In response, officers explained that some current-year pressures were not expected to continue into future years. For example, pressures within waste management were anticipated to reduce once operational improvement projects had been fully implemented. Home-to-school transport pressures had already been partially accounted for within the  ...  view the full minutes text for item 65.

66.

Progress update on the Economic Inactivity Trailblazer programme and the Connect to Work programme (Pathways to Work) pdf icon PDF 203 KB

 

To consider an update on delivery and performance of the Pathways to Work programme, including the Economic Inactivity Trailblazer and Connect to Work programmes, together with programme development, employer activation, VCSE delivery and triage activity.

 

 

Additional documents:

Minutes:

At the Chair’s invitation, Councillor Williams, Cabinet Member for Transport, Jobs and the Local Economy, highlighted that the programme had moved beyond its initial mobilisation phase and was now delivering tangible outcomes for residents across the borough. Members were advised that almost 1,000 residents had engaged with support, more than 200 people had moved into employment, and many others had progressed into training and skills development. Emphasis was placed on the programme’s success in supporting residents facing significant barriers to employment through a combination of Council services, voluntary and community sector organisations and employer partnerships. The development of a “single front door” approach for residents was highlighted along with the growth of employer engagement activity and the introduction of innovative recruitment initiatives aimed at helping residents access sustainable employment. It was noted that whilst funding for the Economic Inactivity Trailblazer Programme was currently confirmed only until March 2027, the programme had established a strong foundation and was already demonstrating benefits for residents, employers and the wider borough.

 

Providing a detailed presentation, Fiona Fletcher, System Service Manager for Pathways to Work, who was also accompanied by Simon Moss, Service Director, Planning, Regeneration and Transport outlined the development of the programme since its launch. Members heard that the Economic Inactivity Trailblazer and Connect to Work programmes were funded through the Department for Work and Pensions via South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA), with Rotherham acting as the system manager. Officers explained that significant effort had been devoted to moving away from traditional programme silos and towards a more integrated system that enabled residents and employers to access support through a single point of contact. Members were advised that over 1,000 residents had now been supported through the Trailblazer and associated programmes, including economically inactive residents and individuals already in work who required assistance to remain employed or progress in their careers. At the time of reporting, approximately 265 confirmed job outcomes had been achieved, with further job starts and offers awaiting formal confirmation. In addition, almost 200 residents had progressed into skills and training programmes. Officers highlighted that job conversion rates had improved significantly during the second year of delivery, increasing from around 20% in the first year to approximately 33% in the current year.

 

Members were informed that the programme had received national recognition through a visit from evaluators commissioned by the Department for Work and Pensions and the National Centre for Social Research. Officers reported that Rotherham’s approach had been identified as distinctive within South Yorkshire because of its integrated delivery model and strong partnership working. Significant progress had also been made within the Connect to Work programme, particularly through supported employment services for neurodivergent residents, individuals involved with the criminal justice system, survivors of domestic abuse and residents at risk of homelessness. Members noted that the Council had recently secured Supported Employment Fidelity Accreditation through the British Association for Supported Employment, (BASE), receiving a Silver Award at the first assessment.

 

The Board also received a detailed overview of the  ...  view the full minutes text for item 66.

67.

Investing in our Community Facilities - Update report pdf icon PDF 186 KB

 

To consider the update on the Community Facilities Programme, setting out completed improvements, remaining works and the funding position.

 

Minutes:

At the Chair’s invitation, Judith Badger, Executive Director of Corporate Services, reminded members that the Council had previously allocated £600,000 through the capital programme to improve community buildings that had fallen into disrepair or, in some cases, had become unavailable for community use. Members were advised that additional external funding had subsequently been secured, increasing the available investment to approximately £1.2 million. Officers explained that this additional funding would enable a greater scope of work to be delivered across the programme, although some projects would continue into the following financial year to ensure all available grant funding was utilised effectively.

 

Presenting the detailed update, Kevin Fisher, Service Director for Property and Facilities Services, reported that the original programme had focused on five facilities: Oaklea Retreat, The Meeting Place, Artworks, the community building operated by Clifton Learning Partnership and Black Hut. Since the programme commenced, two further facilities had been added: the United Multicultural Centre and the Shiloh Centre. Members were informed that improvement works at Oaklea Retreat, The Meeting Place, Artworks, Clifton Learning Partnership and the United Multicultural Centre had all been completed. Work at the Shiloh Centre remained at an earlier stage, with officers working alongside users of the building to determine the precise requirements, which were expected to include roof replacement and internal refurbishment works.

 

Attention was given to the future of the Black Hut, which officers described as the catalyst for the wider programme. Members heard that extensive engagement had been undertaken with community groups, ward members and partner organisations to determine the future requirements of the site. Officers reported that design work was nearing completion and that proposals were being developed to demolish the existing building and replace it with a new modular facility. It was explained that the proposed development remained within the overall programme budget and that discussions were taking place with other Council services to maximise community use of the new facility, including opportunities to incorporate additional community services such as library provision. Officers advised that feedback received on completed schemes had generally been positive.

 

The Chair invited members of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) to raise questions and queries.

 

Councillor Yasseen sought clarification regarding the criteria used to select buildings for inclusion within the programme, particularly the two facilities that had been added after the original programme was approved. Questions were raised regarding how decisions were made about which buildings should receive investment and whether wider considerations relating to community use and accessibility had been considered.

 

In response, Kevin Fisher explained that the Council maintained an ongoing review of its property portfolio and prioritised buildings according to condition, repair requirements and community impact. Officers stated that both the United Multicultural Centre and the Shiloh Centre had come to attention through urgent maintenance issues. The United Multicultural Centre had experienced severe water ingress which affected electrical systems and forced closure of the building, whilst concerns at the Shiloh Centre centred around the building’s physical condition and its importance as a heavily  ...  view the full minutes text for item 67.

68.

Work Programme pdf icon PDF 142 KB

 

To consider the Board’s Work Programme.

 

 

Minutes:

At the Chair’s invitation the Governance Manager, Barbel Gale provided an update on the Board’s work programme.  Members were advised that consideration of the Housing Stock Condition Survey / Energy Efficiency Update had been scheduled for 26 January 2027 as part of the Improving Places Select Commission’s agenda and members of OSMB would be invited to attend. It was reported that the item would include information on the energy efficiency retrofit programme for social housing, including the feasibility and prioritisation of upgrades to heating systems and insulation, the contribution of the programme towards the Council's net-zero ambitions, potential funding opportunities and proposed implementation timescales.

 

An update was also provided regarding the planned scrutiny session with Yorkshire Water and Severn Trent Water. Members were informed that 33 questions had been submitted by seven councillors. The questions primarily focused on environmental performance and wastewater management issues, including sewage spills, pollution incidents, network capacity, infrastructure investment, flooding and the impact of future housing growth on existing infrastructure. Further issues raised by Members included arrangements to support vulnerable residents during service incidents, concerns regarding rat infestations linked to sewer infrastructure, the quality of reinstatement works, customer communication and service standards, and the transparency and accountability of investment and decision-making processes. Several questions sought assurances on how residents and elected members would be informed, consulted and able to monitor future performance improvements. A suitable date to hold this meeting was being investigated.

 

The Board received an update on the Consultation Scrutiny Review. It was reported that six Members had volunteered to participate in the review. Councillor Steele had been appointed Chair of the review, with participation from Councillor Bennett-Sylvester, Councillor Thorp, Councillor Brent, Councillor Currie and Councillor Yasseen, subject to meeting availability. Officers advised that work was underway to identify the key officers who would support the review and to arrange the inaugural meeting.

 

During discussion, Councillor Currie referred to the planned scrutiny work on recruitment, agency staffing and vacancies and requested that consideration also be given to the impact of vacancy factors within the Council's budget-setting process. Councillor Currie was advised that the relevant officer was not present at the meeting and that the request would be referred to officers for consideration as part of the planned work and that a response could be provided outside the meeting if required.

 

Resolved: That the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board:

 

1.    Approved the current work programme.

 

2.    Agreed that the Governance Manager be authorised to make any required changes to the work programme in consultation with the Chair/Vice Chair and reporting any such changes back at the next meeting for endorsement.

69.

Work in Progress - Select Commissions pdf icon PDF 112 KB

 

To receive updates from the Chairs of the Select Commission on work undertaken and planned for the future:

 

  • Health Select Commission
  • Improving Lives Select Commission
  • Improving Places Select Commission

 

 

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Board received updates from the Select Commissions on recent activity and forthcoming work.

 

Update from Health Select Commission:

 

Councillor Keenan reported that, as no meeting of the Commission had taken place since the previous meeting of the Board, there was limited activity to report. Members were advised, however, that two scrutiny reviews were being progressed and expressions of interest had been received from Members wishing to participate. Work was due to commence on the first review, which would examine the provision and accessibility of life-saving equipment across the borough. It was noted that this review would be undertaken jointly with Members of the Improving Places Select Commission.

 

Councillor Keenan also provided an overview of forthcoming business scheduled for the next meeting of the Commission. This would include consideration of winter planning arrangements, safeguarding matters, the Rotherham Safeguarding Adults Board Annual Report, a delivery update report and the Health and Wellbeing Board Annual Report.

 

Update from Improving Lives Select Commission:

 

Councillor Monk noted that the written update contained within the agenda pack pre-dated the Commission's most recent meeting, which had taken place on 3 November 2026. Members were advised that the Commission had considered the Maintaining Schools Long-Term Maintenance Plan and the Intrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse Strategy. Councillor Monk reported that Members had engaged positively with both items, raising constructive comments and questions during discussion. It was further reported that the Commission had requested that both matters return to a future meeting as the work progressed, enabling Members to maintain oversight of their development and implementation.

 

Update from Improving Places Select Commission:

 

Councillor McKiernan advised that the Commission had recently undertaken pre-decision scrutiny of the Playing Pitch Strategy. A key issue arising from the discussion was the importance of ensuring that ward councillors were kept informed of developments affecting playing pitches within their areas. Members had also emphasised the need to ensure that future planning considerations were appropriately reflected in the ongoing management and provision of playing pitch facilities.

 

An update was also provided on scrutiny of the Local Neighbourhood Road Safety Scheme Programme. It was reported that Members had highlighted the importance of evaluating completed road safety interventions to determine whether they had achieved their intended outcomes and delivered value for money. The Commission had stressed the need for stronger post-implementation assessment to ensure that schemes were delivering the expected benefits and lessons could be learned for future projects.

 

Looking ahead, Members were informed of a forthcoming visit to the RiDO Business Centre, which would provide an opportunity to view the range of office, laboratory and workshop facilities available at the site. The Commission was also promoting participation in the forthcoming Cultural Strategy Workshop, scheduled for 15 December 2026, to support Member input into the future development of culture and creative activity across the borough.

 

It was noted that the December meeting of OSMB would be held in Committee Room 1, rather than the Council Chamber.  In response to a query Members were assured that the proposed meeting room  ...  view the full minutes text for item 69.

70.

Forward Plan of Key Decisions

 

To review and identify items for pre-decision scrutiny from the Forward Plan of Key Decisions.

 

Link to: Browse plans - Forward Plan of Key Decisions, 2025 - Rotherham Council

 

 

Minutes:

The Governance Manager, Barbel Gale provided an overview of items provisionally scheduled for the Board's December meeting and highlighted those that may be suitable for pre-decision scrutiny. Members were advised that the proposed agenda included the annual complaints report and potentially the Housing Revenue Account Business Plan, Rent Setting and Service Charges 2027/28. Consideration was also being given to the inclusion of the Crisis Support and Resilience Fund, subject to Members' views on whether pre-decision scrutiny would be beneficial.

 

Members received a summary of items expected to be considered by Cabinet in December 2026. These included the Housing Revenue Account Business Plan, Rent Setting and Service Charges 2027/28, the Rotherham Safeguarding Children Partnership Intrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse Strategy, property transactions, arrangements relating to crisis support within the borough, the Library and Neighbourhood Hubs Strategy, and Cabinet's response to the Board's scrutiny review of lighting columns. Members also noted that applications for business rates relief were scheduled as non-key decisions.

 

During consideration of the Forward Plan, the Chair suggested that the Housing Revenue Account Business Plan, Rent Setting and Service Charges 2027/28 should be included on the Board's agenda for scrutiny, reflecting the Board's usual involvement in considering the proposals prior to Cabinet. Members indicated their agreement with this approach.

 

Discussion then focused on the Library and Neighbourhood Hubs Strategy. The Head of Democratic Services, Emma Hill clarified that the Library and Neighbourhood Hubs Strategy item scheduled for Cabinet in December sought approval for a further period of public consultation rather than approval of the strategy itself, with the final strategy expected to be presented at a later date.

 

Councillor Currie highlighted the relevance of the proposed consultation to the Board's ongoing scrutiny review of consultation and engagement. It was suggested that consideration of the item could provide a useful opportunity to examine how consultation activity was being undertaken and demonstrate the importance that the Council attached to engaging residents in decision-making processes. Councillor Currie also commented that lessons arising from the scrutiny review could help strengthen future consultation activity across the authority.

 

In response, the Chair acknowledged the importance of consultation and noted that the Library Service had generally demonstrated good practice in engaging communities. The Chair then confirmed that, ahead of publication of the agenda, discussions would take place with officers to clarify the nature of the items due to be considered by Cabinet and whether they would be appropriate for scrutiny consideration by the Board.

 

Resolved: That the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board:

1.    Agreed that the following items would be added to the December agenda as part of OSMB’s pre-decision scrutiny work:

a.    HRA Business Plan, Rent Setting and Service Charges 2027-28

b.    Library and Neighbourhood Hubs Strategy

71.

South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority Overview and Scrutiny Committee

 

As part of their role the Chair and Vice Chair of OSMB are appointed to the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (MCA) Overview and Scrutiny Committee. The Chair of OSMB is the Vice Chair on this committee.  

 

This committee holds the MCA to account and ensure that all aspects of the decision-making process are transparent, inclusive and fair.   The Committee are responsible for checking that the MCA is delivering its objectives and that the decisions made in policies, strategies and plans have been made in the best interests of the residents and workers of South Yorkshire.

 

The published agenda packs and minutes can be accessed via: South Yorkshire MCA.

 

Members who have comments and queries regarding any item on any agenda should refer this to the Chair of OSMB and the Governance Manager at the earliest opportunity to ensure they’re reflected in debate during the relevant public meeting.

 

 

Minutes:

The Chair provided the Board with an update on the work of the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) Overview and Scrutiny Committee during the period since the Board’s previous meeting. Members were advised that the Committee had not held a formal public meeting during the reporting period but had instead undertaken three briefing sessions to consider significant developments affecting the South Yorkshire region.

 

The Chair reported that a substantial proportion of the Committee’s activity had focused on developments relating to the future of Doncaster Sheffield Airport, referred to during the meeting as South Yorkshire Airport. Members were informed that briefings had considered proposals to move away from previous lease-based arrangements towards direct acquisition of the airport site. It was reported that the proposal had subsequently been approved by the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority Board. The update highlighted the strategic significance of the decision for the region, reflecting ongoing efforts to secure the future operation and development of the airport as an important economic asset for South Yorkshire.

 

The Board was also advised that the Committee had received a series of briefings concerning the progression of bus franchising proposals across South Yorkshire. These sessions had focused on providing elected members with updates on the development of the franchising model, the stages completed to date and the next steps in the decision-making process. Members heard that further discussions on bus franchising were scheduled to take place later the same day through an additional briefing session. The Chair noted that the issue remained one of the most significant areas of regional transport reform currently under consideration by SYMCA and was therefore receiving ongoing scrutiny attention.

 

No substantive questions were raised by members of the Board following the update, and there was no further discussion on the matters reported.

 

Resolved That: The Overview and Scrutiny Management Board received an update on the activities of the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority Overview and Scrutiny Committee.

 

72.

Call-in Issues

 

To consider any issues referred for call-in from recent Cabinet meetings.

 

 

Minutes:

There were no call-in issues.

73.

Urgent Business

 

To determine any item which the Chair is of the opinion should be considered as a matter of urgency.

 

 

Minutes:

There were no urgent items.